Pasamanick
B.
Some misconceptions concerning differences in the racial prevalence
of mental disease.
Am J of Orthopsychiatry 1963;33:72-86.
Data from Baltimore studies indicate that Blacks do not have higher rates
for psychoses, psychoneuroses, or psychopathological disorders, but do
for mental deficiency.
“Clinicians have stated that, because of the inability of white
psychiatrists to comprehend the nuances of behavior and speech in Blacks,
there is a tendency to overdiagnose psychoses among Blacks.”
“White middle-class examiners are, for cultural reasons or familiarity
with symptoms, more likely to be aware of psychoneurotic manifestations
in whites. There is also a problem of the channeling and content of neurotic
manifestations and minority group variations thereof. Certain behaviors
such as anxiety, hostility and the like may take different forms and thereby
be underdetected in groups removed from one’s own. The different
meanings that attach to the same gestures, words and symbols on a class
and caste basis may also play some role in this discrepancy.”
“As far as the psychoneuroses and psychophysiological disorders
are concerned…the enormous differences found, I believe to be largely
artifacts consequent to the unreliability of diagnosis, which in turn
may follow upon class and caste factors in both examiners and the examined.
A rigorous and intensive attempt at definition of these conditions and
the establishment of reliable and valid criteria is long overdue.”