Flaskerud
JH, Hu LT.
Racial/ethnic identity and amount and type of psychiatric treatment.
Am J Psychiatry 1992;149(3):379-84.
“The purpose of this study was to examine the relationship of racial/ethnic
identity to the amount and type of psychiatric treatment received by white,
black, Latino, and Asian patients in the in the Los Angeles County mental
health system. The patients studied consisted of all adult inpatients
and outpatients seen in all county mental health facilities between January
1983 and August 1988…. Race/ethnicity did not have a consistent
significant relationship to the treatment variables studied. However,
diagnosis had a consistent and highly significant relationship to the
treatment variables studied.”
“Lindsey and Paul (ref) contended that black patients are overrepresented
among admissions to public institutions and that this is related to their
lower socioeconomic status and to institutional racial bias in assigning
treatment. Supporting their argument, an examination of black and white
patients admitted to a psychiatric hospital by the police found that more
black than white patients were admitted (ref). Black patients were more
likely than white patients to receive neuroleptics, compulsory orders,
outpatient appointments, and a diagnosis of schizophrenia and drug-induced
psychosis. The differences found in clinical management were partially
accounted for by differences in diagnosis.”
“There were significant relationships between racial/ethnic group
and some treatment measures. Black race/ethnicity was significantly related
to two treatment measures: number of sessions with the primary therapist
and treatment modality. Compared with white patients, black patients had
fewer sessions with their primary therapist and more treatment with medication.
This latter finding is similar to the findings of Dunn and Fahy that blacks
were more likely to receive neuroleptics than whites. They related this
finding partially to diagnosis, noting that blacks received more diagnoses
of schizophrenia than whites.”
“Asian race/ethnicity was significantly related to two measures
of treatment: number of sessions with the primary therapist and setting
of treatment. Compared with whites, Asians had more sessions with the
primary therapist and were more often treated as outpatients.
Latino race/ethnicity in the present study was significantly related to
only one measure of treatment: setting. Latinos were more often treated
as outpatients than were whites.”