Psychiatr
Serv 1995 Jun;46(6):586-91
Racial differences in treatment of psychiatric inpatients.
Chung H, Mahler JC, Kakuma T.
New York University Medical Center, New York, USA.
OBJECTIVE: The study examined several aspects of inpatient
psychiatric treatment to determine if differences existed between treatment
of African-American and white patients.
METHODS: Using a structured chart review, data were collected
on 76 African-American and 88 white patients consecutively admitted to
an acute inpatient setting with a principal axis I diagnosis of a major
mood or psychotic disorder. Racial differences in treatment were examined
using analysis of variance and logistic regression to assess the effects
of diagnosis and socioeconomic status.
RESULTS: Nonpsychotic African-American patients had shorter
lengths of stay than white patients with similar disorders. White patients
were more likely to be on one-to-one observational status. Clinicians
were more likely to order urine drug screens for African-American patients
with high socioeconomic status than for comparable white patients. African-American
patients with schizophrenic disorders received higher neuroleptic dosages
than white patients with similar diagnoses.
CONCLUSIONS: Most racial differences cited in earlier
studies of psychotic patients were not found or were not statistically
significant once socio-economic status and diagnosis were accounted for.
However, racial differences related to the detection, phenomenology, treatment,
and course of psychotic disorders and the diagnosis and management of
alcohol and drug use disorders and personality disorders were found.
PMID: 7641000 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]