Dowling
PT, Fisher M.
Maternal factors and low birthweight infants: a comparison of blacks
with Mexican-Americans.
J Fam Practice 1987;25(2):153-8.
(Erratum in: J Fam Pract 1988;27(5):551)
“No statistic expresses more eloquently the difference between
a society of sufficiency and a society of deprivation than the infant
mortality rate.” In the U.S. presently, low birthweight infants
represents a large proportion of infant mortality deaths. While the infant
mortality rate has decreased dramatically since the beginning of the twentieth
century, the incidence rate for low birthweight has remained stable. The
incidence of low birth weight is expected to be higher among all minority
groups since they represent a disproportionate proportion of low-income
strata. However, the Mexican-American population, which shares several
sociodemographic risk factors with the black population, has an infant
mortality rate that is very similar to the white population. A study to
evaluate some of the behavioral, demographic, and medical characteristics
among racial minority groups of similar socioeconomic status was conducted
among Mexican-American and black women who gave birth to live infants
at Cook County Hospital in Chicago during 1986. The study enrolled 236
blacks and 236 Mexican-American women.
The incidence of low birthweight infants was 16.1% (38/236) for the blacks
and 5.9% (14/236) for the Mexican-Americans. While the incidence of preterm
delivery was 20% lower among Mexican-Americans than blacks, the difference
was not significant. Regarding the sociodemographic characteristics, Mexican-American
women tended to be older, married, less educated, and less likely to be
on welfare and recipients of food stamps than the black women. Furthermore,
the Mexican-American fathers were more likely to be employed and the black
women were more likely to be employed outside the house (16% vs. 6%).
Significant differences were also observed for the behavioral variables.
Black women tended to smoke and use nonmedical drugs during their pregnancy
than Mexican-American women. Also, a higher percentage (12% vs. 6%) of
the black women gained less than 15 lb during pregnancy. Regarding the
psychosocial variables, Mexican-American women more often reported that
their pregnancy was planned and that they were breast feeding, while the
black women more often reported increased family support. Within the subgroups
comprised of only women with behavioral or medical risk factors, no significant
difference between incidence of low birthweight among the Mexican-American
and black women was observed. In contrast, among the women without any
complications, incidence of low birth weight among the Mexican-American
women (3/138 or 2.2%) was significantly lower than among the black women
(11/98 or 11.2%).
Among the subgroups of Mexican-American and black women with behavioral
and medical complications, the difference in the incidence of low birthweight
was not significant. This may be partly the result of limited sample size.
However, when neither behavioral nor medical complications were present,
the Mexican-American women had a low incidence of low birth weight of
2.2 % despite their cultural displacement, language barriers and poverty.
In contrast, the incidence rate among the black women without behavioral
and medical complications was still 12.2%. Furthermore, the Mexican-American
women who use Cook County Hospital were generally recent immigrants from
impoverished small towns in search of employment, and not immigrants who
are healthier or financially advantaged. Despite the similar socioeconomic
status among the Mexican-American and black women, the groups are quite
dissimilar. The black women in the study shared many similar behavioral
and demographic characteristics that are prevalent among the urban poor,
regardless of race. While the Mexican-American women in the study were
similarly impoverished as the black women, the Mexican-American women
were not urban acclimated. The sociocultural attributes of the Mexican-Americans
may be conducive to delivery of health infants and should be supported
and preserved. Nevertheless, the unhealthy lifestyle of the urban poor
should be addressed.