Sanders-Phillips
K, Davis S.
Improving prenatal care services for low-income African American Women
and infants (editorial).
J Health Care Poor Underserved 1998;9(1):14-29.
Adverse birth outcomes such as infant mortality, low birthweight, preterm
birth, and intrauterine growth retardation are related to prenatal care.
Furthermore, many adverse birth outcomes lead to adverse psychological,
behavioral, and physiological problems in childhood that may continue
into adulthood. Rates of infant mortality and preterm delivery are twice
as high among African American infants as among white infants born in
the US.
The article examines factors that affect access to and use of prenatal
care among poor African American women and strategies that may be effective
in improving these rates. The primary goal of this literature review is
to identify barriers to prenatal care, the limitations of prenatal care
in improving pregnancy outcomes among African American women, proposed
changes in current prenatal care services, and directions for future research.
In the United States, infant mortality of African Americans is approximately
twice that of white infants, while their rate of preterm delivery ranges
from two to three times that of whites. From 1973 to 1983, the incidence
of moderately low birthweight decreased more among white infants than
black infants. Furthermore, during this time, incidence of very low birthweight
(<15000g) increased among blacks, while it declined among whites.
The higher rates of low birthweight may be indicative of the higher incidence
of preexisting and pregnancy-related conditions among black women such
as infections, sickle cell anemia, hypertension, and heart disease. Also,
multiple gestation, which increases the risk of low birthweight, is more
frequent among black than white women.
Numerous barriers to prenatal care exist for black women. Black women
who are impoverished, adolescent, unmarried, have lower level of education
attainment, and have additional young children are less likely to seek
and obtain adequate prenatal care. A major barrier to a poor black woman
is lack of health coverage, particularly private insurance, and other
financial hardships connected with receipt of prenatal care. Lack of education
may contribute to lack of awareness of pregnancy and the importance of
timing prenatal care. Psychological barriers may be more prevalent among
black women. Psychological stressors such as depression are frequent among
pregnant women, while poverty tends to exacerbate all of the psychological
barriers. Also, life stressors, which may increase pregnancy complications,
are more common among poor women. Regardless of socioeconomic status,
racial discrimination intensified by loss of cultural identity and traditional
support system may lead to adverse health and reduced use of prenatal
care among black women. Structural and systematic barriers have also been
identified. The current structure of prenatal care with its focus on "medicalization
of childbirth," which views pregnancy as a pathological condition
and relies on medical technological intervention, may lead to feeling
of depersonalization and negative attitudes to the use of prenatal care
among women. This atmosphere may be exacerbated in public prenatal clinics,
sites where most poor women receive their prenatal care. Public clinics
are associated with brief and hurried physician visits, long waiting room
time, and greater depersonalization than private sources of prenatal care.
Thus, structural and systematic barriers may work in unison to persuade
a poor black woman from using prenatal care services.
Furthermore, prenatal care may have limited effectiveness to reduce preterm
delivery or low birthweight. Precise biological mechanisms leading to
preterm and low birthweight are unknown. In order to improve birth outcomes
among poor women, particularly black women, systematic changes in our
entire socioeconomic structure and not only the health care system are
necessary. Without these comprehensive changes, poor black women may not
benefit from improvements in access to and quality of prenatal care. Also,
high levels of stress are related to unhealthy behaviors, such as alcohol
use, smoking, and illicit drug use, among poor minority women. Research
has shown that "the adverse effects of smoking and illicit drug use
on the fetus may be more pronounced in African American infants."
Although prenatal care may not substantially improve all pregnancy outcomes,
significant benefits are associated with prenatal care. It can get women
back into the health care system and thus may disclose treatable diseases
in the women and provide further health education. However, in order to
reach black women, modifications must be made in our current prenatal
system. The psychological needs of black women must be addressed within
the system and prenatal care should match the needs and risk of the black
women. Future research should explore the "knowledge of factors precipitating
risk behaviors in African American women may facilitate the development
of prenatal care services that more effectively address the underlying
psychological affecting maternal health behaviors during pregnancy."
Although significant medical advances have been made to improve outcomes
for pregnant women and their offspring, psychological issues confronting
pregnant women still need to be addressed. Women need to promote their
own health as well as their infants by maintaining healthy behaviors during
pregnancy. This is particularly relevant to the African American women
who live in impoverished conditions. Thus, we must cultivate a health
care system that "restores the right of women and their families
to make informed choices about their childbirth and provide the level
of support to low income African American women and their children that
will increase the odds that they will survive and prosper in a complex
and often harsh world."