Murrell
NL, Smith R, Gill G, Oxley G.
Racism and health care access: a dialogue with childbearing women.
Health Care Women Int 1996 Mar-Apr;17(2):149-59
Studies have consistently shown for decades that the rates of low birth
weight, preterm delivery, and the ensuing infant mortality rate are twice
as high for African American as for white infants in the United States.
Although factors such as adolescent age, poverty, low educational attainment,
and late initiation of prenatal care are associated with low birthweight
and being African American, the twofold racial disparity persisted even
when controlling for these risk factors. African Americans are more likely
than whites or Hispanics to use outpatient services than private physicians
(Lewin-Epstein, 1991). Continuity of care is often compromised by dependence
on outpatient services and emergency rooms. The shortage of African American
physicians and lack of private insurance among African Americans may add
to dependence on these sources for primary care. Current literature reveals
that greater disparity in health care services exists among impoverished
African Americans than among impoverished whites. Furthermore, the racial
disparity perseveres even among middle class African Americans compared
with middle class whites. However, the literature has never explicitly
addressed the presence of racism and its affect on the health care delivery
system. A qualitative study was developed to explore these issues within
the context of prenatal care system. Interviews were conducted with fourteen
prenatal and postnatal African American women from 1992 through 1993.
The women were recruited from two distinct practices – a family
practice group and a city health clinic. Half of the subjects were eligible
for Medi-Cal (California based Medicaid program) and half had private
health insurance.
Although, overall, the African American women were well educated, their
total monthly family incomes were at most $2000-2500. The pregnant African
American women perceived that they were stereotyped by the non-African
American society as well as the African American society itself. The most
common assumptions were that pregnant African American women are young,
unmarried, have at least two children, are unemployed and are on welfare.
Other less frequent stereotypes were that no father is present in the
household, pregnant African American women do not take care of themselves
and do not receive proper prenatal care, and that they use illicit drugs.
External and internal processing of stereotypes persisted regardless of
the socioeconomic status of African American women. Often the women perceived
their prenatal care as "indifferent, inaccessible, and undignified."
The implications of the study are strengthened by the fact that the data
were independently collected and coded until consensus was obtained to
ensure reliability. However, the study contained only 14 participants
and only anecdotes and impressions from the subjects are presented. Thus,
it is difficult to generalize from 14 pregnant African American women
to the larger African American population. Nevertheless, qualitative research
contains concepts that quantitative research may not be able to fully
capture. Stereotypes must be first acknowledged and confronted before
changes in health care practices can evolve. "The stereotypes- those
accepted by health workers and those internalized buy the women and families-compromise
the quality of care provided and the quality of care received."