Franks
AL, Kendrick JS, Olson DR, Atrash HK, Saftlas AF, Moien M.
Hospitalization for pregnancy complications, United States, 1986 and
1987.
Am J Obstet Gynecol 1992;166(5):1339-44.
Very little epidemiologic research is available about pregnancy complications
that lead to hospitalization in the United States. Data from the National
Hospital Discharge Survey for 1986 and 1987, which uses a representative
sample of non-federal, short-stay hospitals in the US, was analyzed to
obtain a national overview of the public health burden associated with
inpatient care for pregnancy complications. Hospitalizations that involved
an induced abortion, occurred postpartum or included delivery were excluded
since these hospital stays could have lead to a secondary diagnosis of
pregnancy complications, which alone would not have required inpatient
care. Pregnancy complications were divided into two major categories for
the analysis. Antenatal hospitalization referred to a woman who was still
pregnant at time of discharge. Pregnancy loss hospitalization referred
to a woman who was hospitalized for pregnancy complication, but during
her stay incurred a pregnancy loss without the delivery of a live or stillborn
fetus.
In 1986 and 1987, there were approximately 849,200 pregnancy-related
hospitalizations per year that did not involve an induced abortion, postpartum
diagnosis and delivery. There were 14.6 antenatal hospitalizations and
7.6 pregnancy loss hospitalizations per 100 deliveries. Black women had
a 40% higher rate of hospitalizations per 100 deliveries for both categories
than the white women did. Thus, all further analyses were stratified by
race. With respect to antenatal hospitalizations, the ratio decreased
with age among white women and increased with age for black women. At
time of hospitalization, 20.5% of the white women were unmarried, while
64.3% of the black women were unmarried. The antenatal hospitalization
ratio was 60% higher among unmarried than among married white women. In
contrast, the antenatal hospitalization rate among black women did not
vary by marital status. Also, 36.5% of the white women and 66.1% of the
black women had no health insurance. The antenatal hospitalization ratio
was 40% higher among uninsured than among insured white women, while it
was only 14% higher among uninsured than among insured black womem. For
all antenatal diagnoses, the mean length of stay for black women was 3.33
days, approximately one third greater than the 2.5 days for the white
women. With respect to pregnancy loss hospitalization, the ratio significantly
increased from age group 20-34 to age group 35-44 across the white and
black population. At age group 15-19, the ratio for blacks compared with
whites was 4% lower, but by age 20-34 the ratio for blacks was 55% greater
than for whites, and, for oldest age category 35-44, the ratio for blacks
was 76% greater. Marital status did not affect the ratio of hospitalization
for blacks, but the ratio for unmarried white women was almost double
that of married white women. Also, the pregnancy loss hospitalization
ratio was 24% lower among uninsured than among insured black women, while
among white women, the ratio did not vary by insurance status.
A major finding was that blacks had a 40% greater ratio of hospitalization
for antenatal conditions and pregnancy loss management per 100 deliveries
than whites had. The authors cite several possible explanations for the
racial difference. They include actual greater incidence of pregnancy
complications among blacks, greater likelihood of blacks receiving inpatient
than outpatient care for pregnancy complication, greater likelihood of
multiple hospitalizations during pregnancy among blacks, and greater severity
of clinical presentation of complications among the black women. The last
two explanations are compatible with findings that show black women generally
receive less adequate prenatal care than their white counterparts. With
the lack of both appropriate prenatal care and early intervention, pregnancy
complications may progress significantly in black women and require inpatient
care.
The lack of differentiation between multiple admissions of the same person
from hospitalizations for different persons and the paucity of information
in hospital discharge data on sociodemographic factors may limit the precision
and utility of the findings to some extent. Nevertheless, the finding
of this study based upon hospital discharge data demonstrated the magnitude
of the public heath burden of pregnancy morbidity. However, the study
did not account for the indirect burden or cost of pregnancy complication
hospitalization, which includes family disruption, loss of productive
days on part of the hospitalized woman or other individual and emotional
distress. Furthermore, the study suggests that the quality of prenatal
care and medical intervention for obstetric complications vary by race.
Inadequate routine outpatient prenatal care among black women appears
to result in greater likelihood of obstetric complication hospitalization,
which is significantly more costly than outpatient prenatal care.