Barfield
WD, Wise PH, Rust FP, Rust KJ, Gould JB, Gortmaker SL.
Racial disparities in outcomes of military and civilian births in California.
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 1996;150(10):1062-7.
The purpose of this study was to examine whether there are racial disparities
in birth and neonatal outcomes among military personnel in California,
a population for whom financial barriers to health care services is minimal.
Data were drawn from the Maternal and Child Health Data Base of University
of California at Santa Barbara (1981-1995). Data were classified as related
to military personnel and their dependents if the facility of care was
one of twenty-two Army, Navy, and Air Force hospitals, while data regarding
all other hospitals were classified as civilian. White and black racial
groups were defined based on medical records and birth/death certificates;
black racial group included those with Spanish surnames.
Both military and civilian blacks were less likely to receive prenatal
care (black-white RR=0.79 for military and 0.51 for civilian). Over the
nine month period, there were changes in this racial pattern: in the first
month of pregnancy, a higher percentage of blacks than whites received
prenatal care, but, by the second month, 1.5% more whites in military
care and almost 15% more whites in civilian care received care. Differences
reduced after the third month, with a higher proportion of whites than
blacks receiving care every month following the first. Low birth weight
births were also more common among blacks than whites, with the difference
being higher among civilians than military personnel/families. Blacks
had higher fetal and neonatal mortality rates, and there was no difference
in the patterns for civilian versus military personnel/families.
The finding of smaller disparities in receipt of prenatal care among
military personnel/families than among civilians indicated that better
financial coverage of health services was associated with improved utilization
of prenatal care. However, even with the reduction in financial barriers,
black women received less care and, in turn, had poorer pregnancy outcomes
with regard to birth weight and fetal/neonatal mortality rates. The authors
conclude that, "expansions in insurance coverage may require concurrent
improvements in associated systems of outreach and service delivery. The
full promise of financial coverage may depend on a renewed commitment
to the infrastructure of community services to ensure comprehensive access
to all forms of health care." It is important to note that potential
confounders were not measured or tested in this analysis, particularly
health conditions, substance use, education, and stress.