Graham
NM, Jacobson LP, Kuo V, Chmiel JS, Morgenstern H, Zucconi SL.
Access to therapy in the Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study, 1989-1992.
J Clin Epidemiol 1994;47(9):1003-12.
The goal of this study was to assess which factors are associated with
access to antiretroviral therapy, antiviral therapy, antifungal therapy,
and PCP prophylaxis in a large, multicenter AIDS cohort of gay and bisexual
men (MACS).
MACS is a cohort established in 1984-1985 to study the natural history
of HIV-1 infection in gay and bisexual men from four large U.S. cities.
Approximately one-third of the sample was HIV-negative (36.5% of the sample).
From this paper, it is uncertain how this cohort represents the larger
U.S. population of gay and bisexual men with regard to demographic or
illness characteristics. One of the main limitations of this study is
that the cohort is a self-selected group of gay and bisexual men with
relatively high SES. With regard to representativeness, it is important
to note that between 1987 and 1991 an additional sub-sample of men was
recruited with the intention of increasing minority representation.
This analysis focuses on the 1,415 HIV seropositive men who returned
for at least one of the three study interviews from October 1990 to March
1992.
Overall, the use of antiretroviral therapy (zidovudine, didanosine and
dideoxycytidine) was most common among patients with AIDS and among HIV-positive
patients without AIDS who had low (200-500) CD4 counts. Zidovudine was
used by more than 60% of patients in these groups at all follow-up three
visits. Didanosine use and, particularly dideoxcytidine use, increased
over the three visits to include more than 20% of the patients with AIDS
and almost 10% of the HIV-positive patients without AIDS who had low CD4
counts. Combination antiretroviral therapy (two or more of these medication
taken concurrently) increased in these groups over the study period as
well. Approximately 88% of the men with AIDS took at least one PCP prophylaxis
medication by the last visit, as did 75% of the HIV-positive men without
AIDS who had low CD4 counts.
After adjusting for severity of illness and overall health services utilization,
having health insurance (OR=1.32), a college education (OR=1.42) and being
white (OR=1.58) were associated with increased odds of using antiretrovirals
among patients who did not have AIDS but were HIV-positive. The sociodemographic
variables were not associated with antiretroviral use among patients with
AIDS. With regard to PCP prophylaxis, after adjustment for severity and
health services utilization, only having a college education was significantly
associated with medication use; none of the sociodemographic variables
were associated with PCP prophylaxis use among the patients with AIDS.
It is important to note that after adjustment for access to care and
insurance status, non-whites were less likely to use antiretroviral drugs.
The authors did not suggest explanations, but noted that "factors
such as personal choice, social and cultural norms or discriminatory practices
were not ascertained in the MACS cohort," and are presumably potential
explanatory factors.