Easterbrook
PJ, Keruly JC, Creagh-Kirk T, Richman DD, Chaisson RE, Moore RD.
Racial and ethnic differences in outcome in zidovudine-treated patients
with advanced HIV disease. Zidovudine Epidemiology Study Group.
JAMA 1991;266(19):2713-8.
(Comment in: JAMA. 1991;266(19):2750-1; JAMA. 1992;267(18):2472-3.)
This study of zidovudine treatment and racial differences in outcome
among patients with advanced HIV disease revealed the following:
Patient Characteristics
Laboratory characteristics at enrollment suggested a less favorable clinical
status for blacks and Hispanic patients than for whites—particularly
in that the former were more likely to have advanced HIV disease at the
initiation of zidovudine therapy. However, there were no significant racial/ethnic
differences in the mean total white blood cell count or neutrophil count
Survival and Development of Opportunistic Infections
Overall, white patients had the most favorable and black patients the
least favorable outcome:
• Survival rates at 1 and 2 years for white, black, and Hispanic
patients with AIDS were 79% and 40%; 69% and 27%; and 63% and 39%, respectively.
• Black patients with AIDS were markedly more likely to develop
serious opportunistic infectious and, in particular, to develop PCP.
• Black patients with AIDS were notably less likely than other patients
to receive PCP prophylaxis, at both enrollment (37% of whites, 23% of
blacks, and 54% of Hispanic) and during follow-up (75% of whites, 66%
of blacks, and 68% of Hispanics). After adjusting for differences across
centers, there were no racial differences because “those centers
with the lowest and the highest use of PCP prophylaxis tended to be those
centers with, respectively, the highest or lowest representation of black
participants.”
• “Adjustment for risk group status [i.e. iv drug users] had
a minimal effect on the observed racial differences in survival or on
the risk of development of opportunistic infections.”
Zidovudine Dosage
• There were no significant differences between the black, white
or Hispanic patients who received continuous zidovudine therapy, however
“white patients overall received zidovudine for a significantly
greater median proportion of their follow-up time (0.87; range, 0.04 to
1.0) compared with black (0.83; range 0.02 to 1.0) and Hispanic (0.81;
range, 0.02 to 1.0) patients.”
• Although there were no statistically significant differences in
the median time between diagnosis and treatment according to race-ethnicity,
“there was a tendency for white patients to be treated slightly
earlier than other patients.”
In response to these findings, the authors recommend, “Innovative
approaches are needed to ensure more widespread use of and earlier access
to zidovudine therapy and PCP prophylaxis, particularly in the black and
Hispanic communities”