Siminoff
LA, Arnold R.
Increasing organ donation in the African-American community: altruism
in the face of an untrustworthy system.
Ann Intern Med 1999;130(7):607-9.
The authors discuss racial differences among organ transplant donors.
They note that African Americans are much less likely than whites to be
organ donors. This difference has resulted in highly consequential waiting
lists for African Americans who require kidney transplants, but has not
resulted in the same waiting lists for those requiring liver or heart
transplants. The reasons are not clear, but the authors suggested two
factors: (1) only kidney transplant requires HLA matching and (2) African
Americans may be over-represented among patients with diseases that require
kidney transplants but not among patients with diseases that require other
types of organ transplants.
The authors suggested three possible reasons why African Americans donate
less: they have less trust in the medical system, their religious beliefs
preclude donation, and they have less awareness of the need for donation
and/or mechanisms by which one donates.
Although the authors noted there have been positive developments in the
trend toward increased organ donation among African Americans in recent
years, they made three suggestions for further improvement.
1. Encourage African Americans to talk to their families about their
wish to be an organ donor. African Americans are less likely than whites
to donate organ for family members, particularly if there is uncertainty
about the family members’ wishes. Additionally, African Americans
are less likely than whites to discuss this issue with family members.
2. Health care providers should examine their own behaviors for those
that potentially discourage African Americans from donating.
3. Distrust is likely to be due to institutionalized racism rather than
directed at the organ donor system or transplantation specifically. Thus,
any campaign to increase donation must address issues of trust and equity.