Ann
Transplant 1998;3(2):22-4
Organ and tissue donation: are minorities willing to donate?
Daniels DE, Smith K, Parks-Thomas T, Gibbs D, Robinson J.
Department of Applied Health Science at Indiana University, Bloomington,
USA.
The Task Force on Organ Transplantation (DHHS,1986) addressed the issue
of increasing organ donation. The Report of the Task Force recommended
that "educational efforts aimed at increasing organ donation among
minority populations be developed and implemented, so that the donor population
will more closely reflect the ethnicity of potential transplant recipients,
in order to gain the advantage of improved donor and recipient immunologic
matching (DHHS,1986). Donor rates for minorities has increased as follows:
16% in 1988 to 23% in 1995 among cadaveric donors and 24% in 1988 to 28%
in 1995 among living donors. The improvement in donor rates among minorities
may positively affect the transplantation success rate experienced by
organ recipients of the same race. Strategies must be implemented that
will increase the effectiveness and frequency of communication between
minority patients and the medical community. An increase in the effectiveness
of communication between potential minority donor families and the health
care community will contribute to the process of Consciousness Raising
as discussed by Prochasksa. The result of increased awareness of the organ
donation and transplantation process may have a favorable impact on organ
donation. The media has, through public service announcements, paid advertising
and entertainment programming, attempted to promote discussion of organ
donation in the community and within families. Johnson et al. discussed
Mexican-American and Anglo-American Attitudes Toward Organ Donation. The
primary impediment contributing to the disparity of consent rates between
Mexican-American and Anglo-American population occurs with regard to the
donation of organs of relatives. Johnson stated that this impediment to
organ donation can be effectively addressed by promoting family discussion.
Communication within families will inform surviving next of kin of the
desire of the deceased to be an organ donor and hence improve the likelihood
of the donor family consenting to organ donation (Johnson et al., 1988).
The promotion of communication within families must continue to be a goal
of the transplant community regardless of race/ethnicity. Despite the
efforts of the government, the transplant community, the media and the
corporate sector to address the critical shortage of donors in the United
States, the reality is that no community has the supply of donor organs
suitable to meet the need.
PMID: 9869886 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]