Pugh
JA, Stern MP, Haffner SM, Eifler CW, Zapata M.
Excess incidence of treatment of end-stage renal disease in Mexican
Americans.
Am J Epidemiol 1988;127(1):135-44.
The goal of this paper was to estimate incidence rates of treatment of
end-stage renal disease (ESRD) in Texas for three racial/ethnic groups
– Mexican Americans, blacks and non-Hispanic whites – for
the period from 1978 to 1984.
Data for this study were derived from the U.S. census and the Texas Kidney
Health Program, which provides financial assistance for expenses incurred
prior to Medicare eligibility. Enrollment in the program is not required;
therefore, the study sample might be biased by the exclusion of patients
with high enough incomes/complete enough insurance coverage to pay for
medical costs or patients who have trouble documenting eligibility. The
authors showed that a weighted average of 12% of ESRD patients were not
enrolled during the study period; they conducted sensitivity analyses
to ensure bias by racial group could not substantially influence the results.
Blacks have 3.61-4.65 times the ESRD rate of non-Hispanic whites, and
Mexican American have 2.40-3.21 times the rate of non-Hispanic whites.
The excess rate in blacks compared with Mexican Americans is also statistically
significant.
The findings suggested that non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus might
be a major contributor to diabetes-related ESRD, particularly in blacks
and Mexican Americans. Diabetes-related ESRD explains 50-60% of the excess
for Mexican Americans over non-Hispanic whites in ESRD for all etiologies
combined. (Note this suggests excesses must also be found in other diagnostic
categories of ESRD as well.) For the younger ages, the risk of developing
diabetes-related ESRD is similar for Mexican Americans and non-Hispanic
whites, but by 40-49, the risk begins to rise faster for Mexican Americans.
While a similar pattern is found for blacks, the rates in older age groups
(50-59, 60-60, and 70+) for blacks do not rise as steeply as for Mexican
Americans.
Hypertension-related ESRD, glomerulonephritic ESRD, and ESRD from unknown
causes also occur more frequently in both blacks and Mexican Americans
compared with non-Hispanic whites. The male-female ratio is highest for
whites (1.46) and lower for blacks (1.24) and Mexican Americans (1.09).
This is likely to be due to the reversal in the male-female ratio for
diabetes-related ESRD for these two populations.
The authors suggest the excess may be partially explained by higher prevalence
of risk factors for the development of ESRD, including level of glycemic
control, duration of diabetes, coexistent hypertension, proteinuria, development
of non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus at an earlier age, and low
SES, which is associated with obesity.