Hill
HA, Eley JW, Harlan LC, Greenberg RS, Barret RJ 2nd, Chen VW.
Racial differences in endometrial cancer survival: the black/white cancer
survival study.
Obstet Gynecol 1996;88(6):919-26.
The purpose of this study was to examine why black women with endometrial
cancer have higher mortality rates than white women. Data were derived
from the National Cancer Institute's Black/White Cancer Survival Study.
Subjects selected for the current study were black and white women aged
20-79 years who resided in Atlanta, New Orleans, or San Francisco/Oakland
and were diagnosed with primary cancer of the uterine corpus during the
period from 1985 to 1987.
Black women were diagnosed at a later stage than white women: 25% of
blacks versus 10% of whites were stage III or IV at diagnosis. Only 21
women presented with metastatic disease, but the proportion of black to
white women with the disease was more than 3 to 1. Black women were two
times more likely to have poorly differentiated lesions, and, among the
60% of tumors in both races that were adenocarcinomas, black women were
more likely to have serious tumors.
With regard to treatment differences, there were none observed in hormone
therapy, or pre- or post-hysterectomy radiation. Surgical treatment did
vary by race: 29.5% of blacks versus 4.6% of whites received curettage
or less as their surgical treatment; 70.5% of blacks versus 95.4 % of
whites received a hysterectomy. This pattern was consistent across disease
stages. The authors suggest that these data indicate that closer attention
should be paid to whether black women with endometrial cancer are currently
receiving optimal surgical care. They further offer that some of the racial
difference in surgical treatment may result from a high prevalence of
contraindications or high refusal rate among black women.
After adjustment for age, location, stage, tumor characteristics, treatment,
hormonal and reproductive health, comorbidities and health behavior, and
sociodemographic characteristics, blacks were still 1.6 times more likely
to die (all causes) than whites (95% confidence interval = 1.0 to 2.6).
The hazard ratio for blacks versus whites that did not adjust for all
of these variables was much higher, and a comparison of measures before
and after adjusting for these clinical and behavioral factors indicated
that they accounted for 80% of the racial difference in survival.