Petersen
LA, Wright SM, Peterson ED, Daley J.
Impact of race on cardiac care and outcomes in veterans with acute myocardial
infarction.
Med Care 2002;40(1 Suppl):I86-96.
This study assessed racial differences in the use of medications and
invasive procedures for patients with acute myocardial infarction in the
Veterans Affairs (VA) health care system and compared the short- and long-term
mortality for these patients.
The data included all male patients with a primary diagnosis of acute
myocardial infarction discharged from acute care VA facilities in 1994
or 1995. Of the 4,611 patients, 13.1% were black. Black patients were
more likely than white patients to seek treatment at the hospital more
than 12 hours after the onset of acute myocardial infarction symptoms
(34.4% versus 27.7%) and were more likely to have a history of CHF, hypertension,
and stroke. However, the two groups had similar levels of diabetes mellitus,
peripheral arterial disease, prior PTCA, and blood pressure.
With regard to medications, black patients were less likely than white
patients to receive thrombolytic therapy at the time of arrival, using
either the entire sample or restricting the comparison to those who were
ideal candidates (32.4% versus 48.2%). This comparison demonstrated that
racial differences existed in the use of this therapy, even among those
arriving within the eligible time window or without a classic presentation.
Black and white patients were equally likely to receive beta-blockers
at the time of discharge. Among ideal candidates, black patients were
marginally more likely than whites to receive angiotensin converting enzyme
inhibitors at discharge (55.7% versus 49.6%, p=0.07) and were more likely
to receive aspirin (86.8% versus 82%, p<0.05).
With regard to invasive procedures, there were few race differences.
There was no racial pattern in refusal of angiogram, rates of angiogram,
refusal of PTCA, rates of PTCA, or refusal of bypass surgery. However,
blacks were less likely than whites to undergo bypass surgery at the time
of index admission and within 90 days after this admission (6.9% versus
12.5%, p<0.001). In the two subgroups of patients with severe disease
(severe coronary artery disease and left main or 3-vessel disease), blacks
were more likely to refuse bypass surgery and the rate of bypass surgery
was lower. There were no significant race patterns in mortality at 30
days, 1 year, or 3 years.
The authors conclude that “the findings that black patients were
as likely or more likely than white patients to receive beneficial medications
and diagnostic angiography, but less likely to receive thrombolytic therapy
or coronary artery bypass graft surgery, might indicate bias on the part
of physicians. As a reflection of unconscious or conscious bias, physicians
might be less willing to use invasive procedures or “scarce”
resources in minority patients, whom they perceive as less compliant with
treatment plans or less likely to benefit. Physicians might be also less
likely to withhold medication and interventions that do not require intensive
use of hospital resources…Problematic physician-patient communication
could also be responsible for some of the disparities in use of invasive
therapies…”