Manhapra
A, Khaja F, Syed M, Rybicki BA, Wulbrecht N, Alam M, Sabbah H, Goldstein
S, Borzak S.
Electrocardiographic presentation of blacks with first myocardial infarction
does not explain race differences in thrombolysis administration.
Am Heart J 2000;140(2):200-5.
The authors tested their hypothesis that electrocardiographic manifestations
other than that of myocardial infarction (MI) that are more prevalent
in blacks explain the disparity in thrombolysis rates between blacks and
whites. Patients for this study were recruited from those examined at
a major urban teaching hospital with first acute MI as part of a prospective
natural history study of the relation of race and left ventricular hypertrophy
to outcome conducted from March 1993 to June 1995.
Blacks were more likely than whites to be younger, female, hypertensive,
have diabetes, and have a higher systolic blood pressure. With regard
to in-hospital treatment, blacks were less likely than whites to receive
a beta-blocker, thrombolysis, and thrombolysis or early PTCA, and were
more likely to receive a calcium blocker. There were no racial differences
in electrocardiographic localization of MI, although blacks were more
likely to have LVH and were less likely to develop Q waves by the time
of discharge.
On the basis of electrocardiograms, only 64% of the patients were eligible
for thrombolysis. Although a similar proportion of blacks and whites were
electrocardiography-eligible, the use of thrombolysis in electrocardiography-eligible
blacks was considerably lower than in whites. Of the electrocardiography-ineligible
group, whites were twice as likely as blacks to get treated. There were
no significant differences in contraindications to thrombolytic therapy.
In adjusted analyses, black race (RR=0.74), eligibility for electrocardiography
(RR=1.58), time to presentation (RR=0.97), and Q-wave MI at presentation
(RR=1.39) were statistically significantly associated with risk for thrombolytic
therapy.
The authors conclude that, despite the greater prevalence of LVH, electrocardiographic
manifestations of MI in blacks and whites were similar and racial differences
in thrombolysis administration remained significant after accounting for
electrocardiography and clinical eligibility. After discussing possible
race patterns in type/severity of symptoms that were unmeasured in this
study, the authors add, "clearly the area of racial differences in
symptom perception and recognition by care givers merits further analysis
as does the possibility of racial bias."