Lieu
TA, Newacheck PW, McManus MA.
Race, ethnicity and access to ambulatory care among US Adolescents.
Am J Pub Health 1993;83(7):960-5.
The purpose of this study was to describe differences in health status
and in health care access and use among white, black and Hispanic adolescents
in the United States and to evaluate how such differences are influenced
by health insurance. Data for this study were derived from the 1988 National
Health Interview Survey.
Non-white adolescents were significantly less likely than white adolescents
to be in excellent or very good health, but white adolescents had the
highest number of "bed days." Additionally, Hispanics had the
highest number of school-loss days. Black and Hispanic adolescents had
fewer ambulatory care contacts; however, there was no racial difference
in the proportion of adolescents who had seen a doctor within the last
two years. In the multivariate analysis, having insurance was associated
with a notable increase in the number of physician contacts for each race
but did not completely explain the racial variation. Having insurance
was also associated with having seen a doctor in the last two years. Among
the insured, blacks were more likely to meet these criteria (83% of blacks
versus 78% of both whites and Hispanics). Insurance was not associated
with continuity form routine to acute care and did not eliminate racial
disparities in this area. (Blacks were less likely to experience such
continuity.)
In sum, black and Hispanic adolescents had greater health needs and access
problems than they white peers. However, after controlling for predisposing
and need factors, black and Hispanic youth were actually more likely than
white youth to be in compliance with established recommendations for a
routine doctor visit at least every two years. Additionally, black and
Hispanic adolescents in this study were reported to have fewer bed days
than whites despite their worse perceived health status. The authors suggested
that these patterns might be explained by possible cultural differences
in reporting, in addition to social and institutional factors.
Racial differences in health care access and use were found to be due
in part to a lack of health insurance. However, insurance did not completely
explain race patterns. "It appears that universal health coverage
alone will not resolve racial disparities in use of physician services."
The authors suggest that different beliefs regarding health, as well as
discrimination in terms of institutional access or physician behavior
could be an explanation.
The authors conclude that this study demonstrated that black and Hispanic
youth are more likely to seek preventive and less likely to seek acute
care than whites; however, the reasons why are not clear. They also note
that that this study underscores the importance of health insurance, which
substantially increased appropriate health care use, as well as access
to sources of routine care.