Kahn
KL, Pearson ML, Harrison ER, Desmond KA, Rogers WH, Rubenstein LV, Brook
RH, Keeler EB.
Health care for black and poor hospitalized Medicare patients.
JAMA 1994;271(15):1169-74. (Comment in JAMA 1994;271(15):1207-8.)
“After adjusting for patient and hospital characteristics (ie,
removing the effect caused by blacks and people from poor neighborhoods
receiving care in better hospitals), patients who were black or from poor
neighborhoods have worse processes of care.”
“Patients who were black or from poor neighborhoods were more likely
to be discharged in an unstable condition after adjustment for sickness
at admission, patient and hospital characteristics, disease, state, and
time period (P<.001).”
“After adjusting for all covariates, patients who were black or
from poor neighborhoods average 12.6 hospital days, compared with 12.0
hospital days for the other patients. (P<.05)”
No significant differences were found in mortality rates.
“Further research is needed to clarify whether sociocultural and
educational incongruity between providers and patients translates into
misunderstandings about patients’ preferences and expectations,
and to evaluate the extent to which stereotyping, discrimination, or bias
exist in the hospital setting…. We report that racial characteristics
and poverty status also influence the quality of care received by acutely
ill, insured patients after they have gained access to the hospital.”
Ayanian J.
Race, Class, and Quality of Medical Care. (Editorial)
JAMA. 1994; 271(15): 1207-1208.
The studies by Kahn et al. and Peterson et al. “provide some reassurance
that such disparities do not translate into higher mortality rates for
patients who are black or poor. However, the goal of most hospital care
is to improve patients’ functioning and quality of life. Differences
in treatment by race and class may have their greatest impact on these
more subtle, but critical, outcomes.”