Becker
TM, Wiggins CL, Key CR, Samet JM.
Symptoms, signs and ill-defined conditions: a leading cause of death
among minorities.
Am J Epidemiol 1990;131(4):664-8.
The authors hypothesized that non-specific causes of death are likely
to be assigned to persons with unknown medical history or those not receiving
regular health care; therefore, this category may be more frequently given
as a cause of death for minorities in the U.S. than whites. To investigate
these hypotheses, the authors examined death certificate data for New
Mexico for the period from 1958 to 1982.
Death rates from non-specific causes, for both men and women, were higher
in almost all age-gender strata for Hispanic and American Indian persons
compared with non-Hispanic whites. Similarly, the age-adjusted mortality
rates attributed to non-specific causes were consistently higher for minority
men and women than for whites in each four-year time period.
The authors make several arguments based on these data which will require
further investigation. First, it is possible that this reflects lower
utilization of medical care by minorities compared with whites. Second,
it is possible that this reflects fewer autopsies among ethnic minorities
in New Mexico compared with whites. Finally, these data suggest that there
might be substantial bias in ethnic/racial comparisons that make use of
mortality data.